U.S. Supreme Court Justices Are Split on Ecommerce Tax Case

One day into a U.S. Supreme Court case that can reset the balance on collection of tax for ecommerce sales, justices appeared split on the issue arising out of South Dakota.

The case will decide whether the court’s 1992 Quill ruling, which limited taxation to states where merchants have a physical presence, should stand or be overturned. The law is being challenged by defendants Overstock.com, Newegg and Wayfair.com.

South Dakota law passed a law in 2016 requiring out-of-state merchants to collect a 4.5% sales tax if above the threshold of $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions, knowing it violated the 1992 decision. The state then sued the three companies in 2017 to collect sales tax under its law, setting up the high court case.

Various estimates peg the amount of tax revenue that would flow to states at between $8 billion to $23 billion annually. Overturning Quill is favored by states as well as traditional retailers and trade groups, and President Donald Trump, or at least limiting it to catalog companies, which gave rise to the 1992 ruling.

Amazon collects sales taxes on direct purchases from its marketplace in all 45 states that have a tax, plus the District of Columbia, even though it doesn’t have a presence in all of them, but not from third-party sales, which make up about half of its sales.

Supreme Court Justices Anthony Kennedy, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas had already indicated they favored overturning Quill before the case was heard. On Tuesday, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg suggested she would join them, calling the ruling “obsolete,” according to Yahoo Finance. Ginsburg said letting states tax online sales would equate to “equalizing sellers.”

But Supreme Court Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Samuel Alito said the decision on ecommerce taxation should be left up to Congress, Yahoo reported. Sotomayor said the lack of a mechanism for collecting taxes directly from consumers was the real problem, not the Quill ruling.
http://multichannelmerchant.com/ecommerce/u-s-supreme-court-justices-split-ecommerce-tax-case/

Related Posts

FedEx Express enters consultations on workforce reductions as it nears the completion of TNT network integration

FedEx Express announces proposals to resize its European workforce as it nears the completion of the network integration of TNT. These proposals are part of a wider, multi-year growth strategy that enables the European Express business to confidently build on the momentum created in recent years. FedEx acquired TNT in 2016 as part of its European expansion plans, connecting the world’s largest air express network with an unparalleled European road network and global suite of services. Since the acquisition, successful integration has taken place across IT systems and key parts of the air, road and ground networks, and investments have been made in technology and infrastructure. Plans to address the duplication resulting from operating two large European networks connecting similar geographies were presented to European employee representatives and team members today. These proposals will regrettably have a workforce impact of between 5500 - 6300 people across operational teams and back-office functions. In the course of these consultations, the full range of support measures for affected team members will be discussed with works council representatives from across the region. These measures differ by country and may include voluntary redundancy, reassignment to other roles and priority access to open positions. The consultation process will take place over an eighteen-month period in line with local country processes and regulations.

For Back to School, Savvas Supports Educators and Students With Innovative Solutions to Maximize Personalized Learning

As students return to the classroom for the new school year, Savvas Learning Company is helping educators move learning forward with engaging, easy-to-use K-12 solutions that offer data-informed instruction and adaptive technology to take personalized learning to the next level. “A one-size-fits-all instructional approach doesn’t work in a classroom where every student brings their own unique learning style. More than ever, personalized learning is critical in getting students engaged and motivated to learn and supporting academic growth,” said Bethlam Forsa, CEO of Savvas Learning Company. “Teachers know best how to personalize learning for their students. This is why Savvas delivers learning solutions that are powered by adaptive technology, enabling educators to easily tailor instruction to address each student’s learning needs, interests, and abilities.”

Hearst Magazines Names Jon Gluck Executive Director, Editorial Talent, Development and Special Projects

Hearst Magazines announced that Jon Gluck, formerly managing editor of Vogue, has been named executive director, editorial talent, development and special projects, a new role responsible for senior-level editorial recruiting and magazine development. The announcement was made by Hearst Magazines President David Carey and Chief Content Officer Joanna Coles. Gluck assumes his new position on September 5, reporting to Coles and Scherri Roberts, senior vice president, Human Resources. Gluck will be responsible for senior-level editorial recruitment for Hearst Magazines’ new launches and 20 brands in print, and will work closely with existing editors on magazine development. In addition, he will conceptualize new magazines and special projects, such as live events. “To say that the industry is going through an exciting period of change is an understatement,” Carey said. “Jon will play a central role in the transformation of our U.S. media business, both as we evolve our existing businesses, and acquire and start new ones.”
Back To Top
×Close search
Search